Menu

     Everything on our menu is baked fresh. Most of our flavors can be turned into Cakepops, with the exception of  Tres Leches, Tiramisu and Cannoli. What is a Cakepop ?? It is simply a morsel of our scrumptious cake in the form of a lollipop  and dipped in your choice of chocolate !

Although the above  flavors cannot become Cakepops we will try the best to bring you a similar product in these flavors in case you request them.


Build your own Cupcake!

  Cakes             Fillings
    White               Dulce De Leche
    Vanilla              Vanilla Custard
    Chocolate         Chocolate Custard
    Red Velvet         Lemon Custard
    Yellow               Fresh Strawberry preserve (season pricing)
    Lemon



                        Specialty
  Coconut:
 Succulent White coconut cake infused with sweet coconut shavings and topped with zesty lemon buttercream.

 Nutella:
Choose from decadent chocolate or fluffy vanilla cake. This cake will be filled with smooth Nutella cream, and topped with your choice of buttercream or Grandma's chocolate icing.

Black Forest: 
Luscious dark chocolate cake filled with tangy cherry compote and topped with our signature Grandma's chocolate icing or Buttercream.

Tiramisu:
Smooth yellow cake, drizzled with our signature coffee infusion, filled with coffee flavour mascarpone, topped with meringue and dusted with dutch cocoa. These cupcakes must be refrigerated.
Cannoli:
Rich cannoli cream loaded with semi-sweet  chocolate morsels make the irresistible center of our unique cannoli cake. These cupcakes must be refrigerated.

Tres Leches:
Simply Irresistible! Vanilla cake moistened with our 3 milk-rum sauce, topped with fluffy meringue. A non-rum version also available. These cupcakes must be refrigerated.

Boston Cream:
Vanilla cake filled with our smooth custard handed down from grandma's kitchen. Topped with our signature chocolate frosting.

 Rainbow:
These cupcakes are guarantee to make you smile!! Whimsical layers of colorful cake, topped with vanilla buttercream.



**As each batch is hand made there might be slight variations in the apperance of  your cupcakes. We make them specially for you, so please let us know  3-5 days prior to your event.

To place your orders:

                                          A Simple Cupcake
                                    Port Jefferson Sta. NY 11776
                                            (631) 828-2475
                                 rachel@asimplecupcake.com

                              Or FAX your order to: (631) 828-2475